• 0 Posts
  • 55 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 13th, 2023

help-circle





  • Lower Decks is easily the most entertainment for my time I’ve had out of Trek in a while. I’m conflicted, since calling this my favorite feels like cheating: it doesn’t entirely stand on its own since it riffs on everything else Trek.

    In that case, SNW takes the top spot on my list. It’s an incredibly well-oiled production and it shows at every level.

    Bottom of the list is Enterprise, but that’s only because I personally feel the writers squandered a fantastic setting. Star Trek at a lower technology tier just begs for more edge-of-your-seat stakes and problem solving. At the start, it had grit: the ship had no shields, puny weapons, limited warp, a janky universal translator, and everyone was terrified of the transporter. Add to that operating under interplanetary tensions and a fledgling federation that is a relative unknown in the galaxy. Much of this got thrown out in record time, and for what? A temporal causality loop hundreds of years wide, thereby eradicating any agency the crew had, and by extension, our disbelief that they may pull through the next encounter.


  • I’m with you there on Picard. Season one was… okay, but it had some very interesting worldbuilding that was just thrown away at the end. Season two had all kinds of problems: the story was writier’s-strike-levels of half-baked, and the forced time-travel plot just stunk of budget slashing. Season three was fun, but it was wall-to-wall fanservice and that’s why we like it; this too also ignored a lot of plot points from seasons one and two.

    I would have loved to see a more genuine attempt to establish a Next(er) Generation with the support of so much established star power. IMO, there should have been an entire new crew at the end of season three that has us clamoring for season four. Instead, we got that out of Prodigy of all things.










  • Common language used to dismiss bad decisions like this:

    • We need to track and meet our metrics for the quarter
    • Engagement for $FEATURE is down, so we have to take measures to get people to take notice
    • It’s opt-in/opt-out, so it’s the right thing to do
    • It’s only a one time thing and then the system remembers1 what the user selected
    • Only new users are affected - our power users will put up with it
    • It’s just a minor inconvenience, really
    • It’s just a website

    1 - Oh, did you turn off cookies or clear your cache? Sorry about that.




  • It has been pretty depressing to me that the tech literate have been so easily lulled into accepting such things in the name of “cool toys” and “security” virtually everywhere in modern life besides the PC/laptop/server spaces.

    From my exposure to supporting said folks with PC related problems, its easy to see the reality here. Phones provide a streamlined experience with zero frills. They don’t want super flexible computing devices, they want appliances. More to the point, the level of care and maintenance needed to have a top-shelf PC experience is time and effort most people would rather not expend. Doing this right was inconvenient to begin with, and left the field wide open for anything that would be easier.